How we score websites
The steps behind every Sitefety report, what the 0–100 score means, and what a report cannot tell you.
Last updated
Step by step
- Choosing a site. A reviewer decides which website to research. Readers can ask us to look at a site, but a request is not a promise of a report.
- Hands-on research. The reviewer goes through the site and relevant public information personally. Nothing is scanned automatically and nothing is written by AI.
- Logging evidence. Each observation is recorded on its own, and a written account of the research is prepared.
- Judgement. The reviewer sets the Trust Score, writes the risk notes and sums up the bottom line.
- Publishing and upkeep. The report goes live with its research date and is revised when we learn of relevant changes or of a confirmed factual error.
The checklist
The reviewer works through the areas below wherever they apply to the site in question. Not every area fits every website, and a report only describes the checks that were actually carried out.
- 1
Who runs the site
Does the website say who operates it? Are the company name, address and ways to get support given, and do they match each other?
- 2
Domain records
What public domain records show, looked up by hand — for example roughly how long the domain has existed and any visible registration details.
- 3
Connection and browser warnings
Simple checks anyone can repeat: is the site served over HTTPS, and does the browser show any certificate or security warning?
- 4
Rules and policies
Whether terms, privacy information, refund or cancellation rules and similar policies exist and are written clearly enough to follow.
- 5
The offer itself
Are prices, promises and claims clear, consistent and believable? Does anything on the site look designed to mislead?
- 6
Outside sources
Other public sources the reviewer consulted where relevant, such as official registers or published warnings from authorities.
The evidence log
Observations in a report are sorted into five groups:
- In its favour — things that count towards trusting the site.
- Concerns — things that worry the reviewer or leave questions open.
- Security notes — simple security points a visitor can confirm.
- Domain notes — what public domain records show.
- Other notes — anything else the reviewer found relevant.
The Trust Score
The Trust Score runs from 0 to 100 and sums up the reviewer’s overall view. The reviewer sets it after weighing all the evidence together; it is not calculated by software, and the checklist areas have no fixed weights. It is always an editorial opinion tied to the date of the research. On the page it appears as ten bars — one lit bar for every ten points.
| Range | Label | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 80–100 | Solid | The reviewer found little or nothing that worried them when the research was done. |
| 60–79 | Fair | Some open questions or minor concerns came up; the evidence log explains them. |
| 40–59 | Caution | Several concerns came up during the research; take extra care. |
| 0–39 | Poor | The reviewer recorded serious concerns about this website. |
Risk levels
Every report also gives a risk level: Low risk, Moderate risk, Elevated risk, High risk. Normally it follows from the score range. When the evidence calls for it, the reviewer can set a different level and explains the reason in the risk notes.
Known limits
- We work only with public information and what a visitor can see — we have no access to a site’s internal systems.
- We do not run security audits, penetration tests or malware analysis.
- Things can change after the research date, so always check the dates on a report.
- A high score does not guarantee safety, and a low score does not prove fraud. See the Disclaimer.